Put health at the heart of the new government
The new government must set out an ambitious goal to improve the nation’s health and reduce inequalities, aligning action across government departments and providing leadership to all of society to deliver this goal. This needs to be a key driver of government policy over the next decade and beyond.
The Health Foundation has convened an expert panel to develop detailed recommendations for how to create a long-term shift towards a prevention-led approach across government. The panel – which will publish its final report later in 2024 – will make recommendations on areas including:
- how targets for health improvement and health inequalities can be used as part of a wider strategy and whether these targets should be statutory
- the structures and roles needed in the centre of government to drive an ambitious approach to strengthening the building blocks of health
- support and powers that will be needed by local, regional and national delivery agencies to play their role fully
- how to ensure accountably for delivery, including considering the value of an independent body to review progress and hold government to account
- the funding mechanisms that will best incentivise long-term policymaking to improve health and tackle inequalities.
Not all the actions we have highlighted require additional funding. Many are about how funding can be protected for long-term preventive action, rather than diverted to acute need; how existing money across government can be focused on preventing ill health, and how funding can be fairly allocated to local areas to better meet need.
To address the imbalance between spending on acute and preventive action, government needs to create a system of public spending decision making that incentivises and supports long-term preventive investment. A new category within government expenditure – Preventative Departmental Expenditure Limits (PDEL) – to classify and ringfence investment for prevention, would signal the importance of investment in prevention, enabling departments to be held to account for preventive spending, and providing a baseline to track whether the balance of spending is shifting toward prevention. Separating prevention spend in this way would help to ensure that budget holders are not forced to choose between helping people in need now and preventing such needs arising in future. To inform the practices required to track and measure prevention spend, we are working with CIPFA to understand the extent to which local authorities’ spending on preventative action can be quantified.
Address gaps in the building blocks of good health
A cross-government strategy is needed to drive action on the building blocks of health, tackling critical gaps in these that cut lives short, including in income, employment and housing, particularly in more deprived parts of the UK. This should include:
- reforming the welfare system in ways that will keep families out of poverty
- supporting people with ill health or disabilities who are out of the labour market but want to work to do so, and working with employers to keep people in-work and in good health in the first place, including through reform to Statutory Sick Pay and improving job quality.
- increasing access to secure, decent housing including by bringing back a strengthened Renters Reform Bill in the next parliament that abolishes no-fault evictions and improves the Decent Homes Standard, applying it to the private rented sector.
Government should also work with business to ensure that good business practice is a solid building block of health. This includes supporting employee health, promoting healthier workplaces, and helping those with health challenges to remain in work. Government can support employers, including by raising awareness and uptake of the Access to Work scheme; extending subsidies for Occupational Health provision to smaller businesses; advocating for inclusive recruitment practices; reforming the Apprenticeship Levy; developing a support service with disability experts; and encouraging employers to introduce improvements that benefit health, such as around working conditions and remuneration, supported by financial incentives.
Take population-level action on the leading risk factors for ill health
Tobacco, unhealthy food and alcohol remain the leading causes of preventable ill health in the UK and are key drivers of inequalities. Population-level policy approaches that support everyone to be healthy are likely to be the most effective and equitable, and the public is supportive of greater national action. Yet despite this, recent governments have favoured policies aimed at supporting individual behaviour change and largely neglected population-level approaches.
A new government needs to prioritise population-level action, including bolder use of tax and regulation. This should include:
- minimum unit alcohol pricing in England (which has been implemented in Scotland and Wales)
- delivering the smoke-free generation policy alongside banning tobacco sales in supermarkets and online
- introducing the planned ban on unhealthy food advertising on TV before 21.00 and online, and expanding the Soft Drinks Industry Levy to include unhealthy food, as recommended in the National Food Strategy.
The public also supports local government having more responsibility for tackling harms from tobacco, alcohol and unhealthy food and there are a range of policies that could help, including:
- adding health as a licensing objective for alcohol licensing decisions
- allowing local authorities to limit advertising of unhealthy food and alcohol on non-council owned advertising spaces
- introducing tobacco licensing for retailers
- more closely integrating planning and public health at both local and national levels.
These policies and their implementation are described in more detail in our recent briefing.
Enable and support (including through sufficient funding) approaches led by local and combined authorities
Local and regional authorities hold responsibility for many of the key building blocks of health and play an important role in supporting local communities and the voluntary sector. They will need sufficient and sustainable funding for local areas, with multi-year settlements and appropriate workforce planning and flexibility on how money can be spent most effectively to meet local needs.
Adequate funding is needed for public health infrastructure at national and regional levels, and to reverse cuts to local public health budgets to boost investment in local public health interventions. These provide excellent value for money, with each additional year of good health achieved in the population costing £3,800 – three times lower than the cost of each additional year of good health resulting from treatment in the NHS (£13,500).
A fair system is needed for the allocation of central government funding for services that support health. On average, more deprived areas receive more funding than less deprived areas, but they tend to receive a lower share of overall government funding relative to their estimated local needs than less deprived areas. This is particularly the case for local government funding, with the most deprived fifth of areas receiving, on average, 9% less than their estimated share of needs (£92 per person). The least deprived receive on average 15% more local government funding than their share of needs (£108 per person). Problems are exacerbated by longstanding workforce shortages in areas such as trading standards, licensing and planning. For example, trading standards officer numbers fell by up to 50% between 2008/09 and 2018/19, over half of local authorities report environmental health vacancies of more than 6 months, and 82% of councils had difficulties hiring planners in the past year.
Reorient health services to prevention
Preventing ill health is a core purpose of health services, and the NHS delivers services for the prevention as well as the early detection and treatment of disease. These include screening programmes, vaccinations and prevention of non-communicable diseases, including cardiovascular disease and diabetes.
Policymakers already expect NHS services to contribute to prevention in a variety of ways, but the promise of these plans are far from being fully realised. The 2019 NHS Long Term Plan promised more support for people at risk of poor health outcomes due to smoking, alcohol and obesity, but progress was disrupted by the pandemic, which has also led to higher than expected demand for some of these services. More widely, social prescribing – which aims to create health and prevent illness by connecting people with local community assets like charities, social groups and advisory services – has been rolled out across England, but more disadvantaged patients may face greater barriers to accessing support.
The creation of integrated care systems (ICSs) also provides opportunities to improve health outcomes and address inequalities in local populations, by developing population health management approaches and working with local authorities. However, these priorities risk being crowded out by a short-term focus on more immediate pressures on the NHS and severe financial challenges facing local authorities.
Primary care and community health services are central to delivering these preventative services, but the NHS Long Term Plan commitment to invest a growing proportion of the NHS budget in these services has not been met. General practice is in crisis, with public satisfaction at record lows and the most acute pressures in more deprived areas, which receive less funding and workforce relative to their population health needs. There are also recent reports of funding for preventative services such as vaccinations and screeningdelivered by the NHS being cut by 3.5% (around £50m) to meet funding shortfalls elsewhere. Much has also been made of the potential for technology, genomics and artificial intelligence to deliver personalised prevention services and advice at scale. While there is promise in some areas, this potential remains a long way from being realised.
Beyond the provision of health care services, NHS organisations can contribute to the health of the population through their roles as ‘anchor’ organisations rooted in local communities. This includes as large employers providing good work and healthy workplaces, through using their purchasing power for local and social benefit, reducing their environmental impact, and supporting local communities.
The NHS's role in prevention needs to be given greater priority under a new government. This will require:
- growing the share of funding going to primary, community and preventative services, in line with the public’s priorities. Adequate funding must be protected in the face of acute pressures arising from near-record waiting lists and must be allocated fairly by need
- a new deal for primary care, including a focus on tackling the ‘inverse care law’ that leaves practices in poorer areas underfunded and under-doctored compared with richer areas
- ICS spending and action to improve population health and tackle inequalities in health – including due to ethnic background or socioeconomic deprivation – should form a proportionate focus for oversight of ICSs by national bodies.