Dismantling PHE in the midst of a pandemic carries serious risks Joint letter to the Sunday Telegraph from the Health Foundation, Nuffield Trust and The King's Fund

24 August 2020

Dismantling Public Health England (PHE) in the midst of a pandemic carries serious risks.

The public health system has been tested to its limits during the first wave of this pandemic, and it is surely right that the government should make changes if needed. But decisions of this magnitude need to be informed by evidence, and it is not yet clear what needs to change, nor what the risks of this huge upheaval might be.

Infection control is the largest item in PHE’s £300 million budget. It makes sense to link this activity with the work of the NHS Test and Trace programme and the Joint Biosecurity Centre. But increased focus on infection control must not come with a loss of focus on the other areas of PHE work – tackling major avoidable public health challenges such as obesity and growing health inequalities. These result in more deaths and disability than COVID-19, particularly affecting the areas that the government has pledged to 'level up'.

There has already been a 16 percent reduction in PHE’s budget on these issues and a 22 percent cut to the public health grant for local authorities since 2015/16. Without adequate funding, the new National Institute for Health Protection is likely to face many of the problems which have dogged its predecessor.

Dr Jennifer Dixon
Chief Executive, the Health Foundation

Nigel Edwards
Chief Executive, Nuffield Trust

Richard Murray
Chief Executive, The King’s Fund

But decisions of this magnitude need to be informed by evidence, and it is not yet clear what needs to change, nor what the risks of this huge upheaval might be.

This letter was first published in the Sunday Telegraph on 23 August 2020.

Further reading

Analysis

Creating healthy lives

September 2019
Analysis

This publication makes the case for an ambitious, whole-government approach to long-term investment...

Press release

PHE reorganisation is highly risky and justification for the change has not been fully set out

18 August 2020
Press release

Health Foundation response to government’s announcement of plans to establish a new public health...

You might also like...

Chart

COVID-19 policy tracker 2020

Chart

A timeline of the national policy and health system responses to COVID-19 in England in 2020.

Chart

Huge variation in the proportion of over 80s who have had the first dose of the COVID-19 vaccine

Chart

New data published by NHS England and Improvement shows huge variation in the proportion of over 80s...

Chart

NHS Test and Trace performance tracker

Chart

Our latest analysis on the performance of NHS Test and Trace (up to 30 December).

Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101 copy

Get social

COVID-19 has resulted in the need for better support to NHS staff to use #PPE safely. @ImperialNHS introduced a P… https://t.co/hoSMfkH0LT

Follow us on Twitter
Kjell-bubble-diagramArtboard 101

Work with us

We look for talented and passionate individuals as everyone at the Health Foundation has an important role to play.

View current vacancies
Artboard 101 copy 2

The Q community

Q is an initiative connecting people with improvement expertise across the UK.

Find out more